• Home
  • Forms of Government
  • World History
    • World History Timeline
    • Hall of Evil - No Good Oligarchs
    • World History First Semester >
      • Ancient Sumer
      • Ancient Israel
      • Ancient Babylon and Persia
      • Ancient Egypt
      • Ancient Greece
      • Ancient Rome
      • Byzantine Empire
      • Middle Ages
      • Rise of Modern Nations
    • World History Second Semester >
      • Christmas Break
      • Protestant Reformation >
        • World Religions & Christian Denominations
      • Post Reformation Europe
      • Early America and England
      • French Revolution
      • Age of Industry
      • Victorian Era
      • World War I
      • Russian Revolution
      • 20th Century Liberalism
      • World War II >
        • Holocaust Survivors
        • The Third Reich Video
        • Propaganda Cartoons
      • Cold War Era
      • Rise of Globalism
      • Final Thoughts
      • Semester Project
    • HIS1005 Links Western Civ
  • British Literature
    • Literary Devices & Figures of Speech
    • Brit Lit Outlines
    • 01-02 Heroes of Old
    • 03 Lit & Community
    • 04 Changing Society
    • 05 Renaissance Humanism
    • 06 Reformation & National Identity
    • 07 Renaissance Poetry
    • 08-11 Shakespeare >
      • As You Like It
      • Much Ado About Nothing
    • 12 Civil War & Restoration
    • 13-14 Early Neoclassical
    • 15 Age of Johnson >
      • She Stoops to Conquer
    • 16 Voices from the Outside
    • 17 Signs of Change
    • 18-19 Major Romantics
    • 20-22 Early Victorians
    • 23-25 Late Victorians
    • 26-30 Modern & Contemp Period >
      • Pygmalion
      • The Lord of the Rings
      • Orwell - Animal Farm
    • old Neoclassical Period
  • American Literature
    • American Lit First Semester
    • Pudd'nhead Wilson
    • American Lit Second Semester >
      • American Lit Civil War Authors
      • Short Stories of American Lit
  • American History
    • American History Extra Credit Assignments
    • Amer Hist Semester Project
    • 1-3 Colonial America
    • 4 American Revolution
    • 5 The Constitution
    • 6 The New Nation
    • 7 Expanding Nation
    • 8-9 Growing Nation Dems & Whigs
    • 10-11 Slavery, Abolition, & Crisis
    • 12-13 Civil War
    • 14 Reconstruction
    • 15 Moving Forward
    • 16 Gilded Age
    • 17 Business of America
    • 18 Beginnings of Modern Age
    • 19 Triumph of Progressivism
    • 20 America & Great War
    • 21 America in Twenties
    • 22 New Deal
    • 23 World War II
    • 24 Postwar America
    • 25 The 1950s
    • 26 Turbulent 1960s
    • 27 The 1970s
    • 28 Reagan-Bush Era
    • 29 The 1990s
    • 30 New Millennium
    • Washington DC Tours
  • American Government Home
    • Definitions of Common Terms
    • American Govt Assignments
    • Christianity IS Political
    • Ch 1-2 Government Intro >
      • Western Civilization
      • Natural Rights - Right to Life
    • Ch 3 Shaping of Amer Republic
    • Ch 4 Constitution
    • Ch 5 Legisl Branch - Congress
    • Ch 6 Exec Branch - Presidency
    • Ch 7 Exec Branch - Bureaucracy >
      • Educational Liberty
    • Ch 8 Judicial Branch - Federal Courts
    • Ch 9 Bill of Rights & Other Amendments >
      • 1st Amendment
      • 2nd Amendment
      • 4th Amendment
      • 5th Amendment
      • 16th Amendment
      • 17th Amendment
    • Ch 10-12 American Federalism
    • Whatever Happened to Justice
    • Socialism Testimonies
    • Socialism & Marxism
    • Totalitarianism
    • Political Parties
    • Prejudice & Intolerance
    • Woke v. Awake
    • Social Justice
    • Victor - not Victim
    • Critical Race Theory
    • Modern Idolatry
    • Feminism
    • Miscellaneous
    • Dinesh
  • Economics Home
    • Economics Assignments
    • Current Events
    • Economics Weeks 1-4
    • FDR's Second Bill of Rights
    • Ch 1-2 Economists & Econ Laws
    • Compassionate Capitalism
    • Ch 3 Factors of Production
    • Ch 4 Supply & Demand
    • Ch 5 Free Market Capitalism
    • Wealth Inequality
    • Poverty
    • Ch 6 Competition
    • Ch 7-8 Efficiency of Prod & Saving
    • Ch 9 Money
    • Ch 10-11 Government & the Economy
    • Ch 12 Socialism, Communism, & Command Economies
    • Your Future
    • Freedom Rankings
    • Energy Policy
    • Free Market vs Keynesian Economics
    • Economics Miscellaneous
  • HIS 1007
  • HIS 1005
  • Cabaret!
  • Speaking Topics
  • Worldview
  • Propaganda
  • College Writing Seminar
  • Writing: College Prep
    • College Prep - Helpful Links
    • Writing Basics
    • Five Paragraph Essay Sources
  • Writing: Developing Style
  • Literature-Great Books I
  • Literature-Great Books II
  • Writing - Level A
  • Writing - Level B
  • Helpful Handouts!
  • ACT Prep - Grammar & Writing
  • World Literature
  • Treblemakers
  • Cultural Revolution
  • US History 2520
  • Narcissism & Prodigals
  • Graduation
    • Graduation Forms
MRS. MUELLER'S WORLD!
Welcome!
Ch 9 Bill of Rights & Other Amendments

"A right is something the government can't do to you." (Senator Mike Lee)

Negative Rights and Positive Rights
Picture
Redefinition of Rights
FDR's Second Bill of Rights
Near the end of World War II, FDR proposed a "Second Bill of Rights" that would fundamentally transform the nature of rights. He believed that people should have rights to have certain things provided to them by the State!  (A right to get something from the government is a "positive right."  It means that others have a duty to provide something to you.)  This signaled a 180 turn from the Constitutional view of rights as articulated in the Bill of Rights.  According the founding principles, people have natural, inherent rights to life, liberty, and property, and the Bill of Rights was designed to protect people from the government encroaching upon these pre-existing, inherent rights.  (A right to be protected from encroachment is a "negative right."  It means that others have a duty to refrain from infringing on your life, liberty, or property.) FDR was proposing a new definition of rights that placed a duty on some to provide something to others.  Thus, FDR's approach involved a perspective toward rights that would deny some people their natural rights while providing nice things to others in exchange for votes.

​A right to get something from the government is a "positive right."  It means that others have a duty to provide something to you. The Social Justice movement, Progressivism, Leftism, Socialism, and Marxism are based on this view of rights.
A right to be protected from encroachment is a "negative right."  It means that others have a duty to refrain from infringing on your life, liberty, or property.  America's Constitution was based on this view of rights.
​There are two ways to understand what a right actually is. Negative rights provide citizens “freedom from” governmental intrusion. They prohibit government from acting. Positive rights, on the other hand, require government to act in order to provide “freedom to” do or enjoy certain things. Can these two types of rights coexist within the same regime?

For more information on John Locke and Natural Rights


Bill of Rights!  


14th Amendment
What Is Birthright Citizenship? | 5-Minute Videos | PragerU
Premiered May 19, 2025 5-Minute Videos
​
Do children born on U.S. soil automatically become American citizens? Many claim the Fourteenth Amendment of the Constitution guarantees that they do. Are they right? Amy Swearer, Senior Legal Fellow at the Heritage Foundation, confronts this question head-on.
Home
American Government
American Literature
World History

Literature Great Books
​
Picture
Proudly powered by the Lord!